The New York Yankees' rotation has been a hot topic this season, but now the team faces some unexpected upheaval. In this week's mailbag, we tackle two pressing questions from fans—one about a struggling catcher and another about the shifting balance of power between the National and American Leagues.
Should the Yankees give J.C. Escarra more starts behind the plate?
It's a fair question, given Austin Wells' slow start at the plate. But the answer is a firm no. Catcher is a unique position where defense and game-calling matter just as much as offense. Wells ranks in the 97th percentile in framing, a key reason the Yankees' pitching staff is among the best in baseball. Offensively, while Wells' 70 wRC+ isn't pretty, Escarra's 47 wRC+ is worse. Escarra also strikes out at a higher rate (23.4%) and walks less (6.4%) compared to Wells' 15.8% walk rate. We may not see the .800 OPS Wells flashed in the minors, but he's likely to turn it around enough to avoid being deadweight while his defense remains elite.
Why is the NL suddenly stronger than the AL?
The interleague records tell the story. Outside of the Giants and Marlins (a combined 6-18 vs. AL teams), every other NL club has a winning or even record in interleague play this year. With MLB's more balanced schedule, we're seeing the NL's depth shine through—something that was often overlooked when media focused heavily on the AL. This shift in power is real, and it's making for a more competitive landscape across baseball.
