The Pittsburgh Steelers are still searching for answers at quarterback, and the picture is getting more complicated by the day. After selecting former Ohio State standout Will Howard in the 2025 NFL Draft, the team followed up this year by drafting Penn State's Drew Allar. But despite adding two young arms to the roster, new head coach Mike McCarthy has made no secret of his desire to bring back Aaron Rodgers—who led the Steelers to an AFC North title last season.

Rodgers, for his part, remains undecided about whether to play another season or retire. Reports initially surfaced that the four-time MVP was in Pittsburgh over the weekend to discuss his future with the franchise, but as of Tuesday afternoon, no official meeting had taken place. While the clock ticks on Rodgers' decision, one longtime Steelers reporter is making a bold case: the team needs not only Rodgers but also veteran Mason Rudolph.

Mark Kaboly recently took to X to explain that the Steelers have no intention of putting Allar or Howard on the field this season unless injuries force their hand. After an offseason loaded with veteran additions aimed at competing now, Kaboly argues that a steady, experienced presence under center is essential. He believes Rodgers is the right man for the starting job, but if the team truly wants to develop its young quarterbacks without rushing them, Rudolph is the ideal backup.

"They have to keep Rudolph around if the plans are to slow-play their two young quarterbacks," Kaboly wrote. "If the goal is to win now, which it is, coupled with moving forward 100% with Allar or Howard next year, Rudolph has to be the backup."

The logic is clear: with so much talent added to the roster, Pittsburgh can't afford to waste a season on growing pains. A veteran like Rodgers provides stability and a championship mindset, while Rudolph offers a reliable safety net who knows the system. Without both, the Steelers' carefully laid developmental plan could unravel, potentially setting the franchise back years.

For a team that prides itself on toughness and tradition, the quarterback room is suddenly the most important—and uncertain—position on the field. All eyes are on Rodgers' next move, but the smart money says Rudolph's role is just as critical.