The NFL is a quarterback-driven league, and for Buffalo Bills fans, every game on the 2026 schedule starts with one question: Who’s under center for the other team?
With the 2026 schedule now released, we’ve broken down all 14 quarterbacks the Bills are set to face this season. From rising stars to seasoned veterans, here’s how they stack up—from the most manageable matchups to the true tests of Buffalo’s defense.
14. Malik Willis (Miami Dolphins)
Willis remains a mystery. With just a 3-3 record as a backup and now joining a rebuilding Miami squad, he’s the biggest unknown on the list. Expect growing pains.
13. Geno Smith (New York Jets)
Smith has proven he can start in this league, and the Jets’ roster is improving. But his tendency for erratic throws and turnovers keeps him near the bottom of this ranking.
12. Shedeur Sanders or Kirk Cousins (Las Vegas Raiders)
It’s unclear who will be under center for the Raiders by Week 6. Sanders is a highly-touted rookie, while Cousins is a steady veteran. Both feel like middle-of-the-pack options for now.
11. C.J. Stroud (Houston Texans)
Stroud’s stock is tricky. After his worst season in 2025, he’s hard to pin down. If the electric version of Stroud from prior years shows up, he could climb this list fast.
10. Kyler Murray (Minnesota Vikings)
This ranking factors in the offense around the QB, and Murray lands in a promising spot. His first season with the Vikings brings loads of potential on paper. Now, it’s about execution.
9. Jordan Love (Green Bay Packers)
Love can be inconsistent week to week, but his high floor keeps him competitive. He’s the kind of QB who can drag his team to any finish line.
8. Bo Nix (Denver Broncos)
Nix’s ranking is tied tightly to head coach Sean Payton’s system. He flashed brilliance in 2025 but wasn’t always consistent. Still, you can’t forget his playoff win over the Bills—that counts for something.
7. Jared Goff (Detroit Lions)
Goff fits perfectly in the middle of this list. He gets the ball out fast and runs the offense like a well-oiled machine. Not flashy, but reliably effective.