The NFC South quarterback hierarchy has undergone a dramatic transformation heading into the 2025 season, with breakout performances and surprising moves reshaping the division's signal-caller landscape. What was once Baker Mayfield's division to command has become a proving ground for emerging talent and veterans looking to redefine their careers.
Perhaps no story is more compelling than that of New Orleans Saints quarterback Tyler Shough. Entering the season with modest expectations, Shough has silenced doubters by emerging as not just the Saints' franchise quarterback, but one of the premier passers in the entire division. His late-season surge—leading New Orleans to four wins in their final five games while amassing 2,384 passing yards and 10 touchdowns—has positioned him as a cornerstone for the Saints' future.
The question on everyone's mind: where does Shough land in the division's quarterback rankings? Is Baker Mayfield still the king of the NFC South? What about Carolina Panthers' young gun Bryce Young? And how will Atlanta's quarterback situation shake out after Michael Penix Jr.'s devastating season-ending knee injury and the addition of another veteran signal-caller?
Let's break down the NFC South quarterback room, including projected first and second-string options for each team.
Kenny Pickett, Backup Quarterback
The former first-round pick continues his NFL journey after being drafted by the Pittsburgh Steelers. In 2025, Pickett saw action in six games with the Las Vegas Raiders, completing 62.2% of his 45 passes for 188 yards, one touchdown, and two interceptions. At 27 years old, he'll have the opportunity to refine his game behind Bryce Young in 2026. History has shown that first-round quarterbacks can rejuvenate their careers—just ask Sam Darnold. Could Pickett be the next to follow that path in 2027?
Jake Browning, Backup Quarterback
After five seasons with the Cincinnati Bengals, Browning signed a one-year deal to serve as Baker Mayfield's backup. He appeared in five games in 2025, completing 64.8% of his passes for 771 yards and six touchdowns. Browning became a fan favorite in 2023 when he stepped in for an injured Joe Burrow, and his steady play continues to make him a reliable option off the bench.
Spencer Rattler, Backup Quarterback
Rattler's ranking remains unchanged from last season, but the former Oklahoma and South Carolina standout finds himself at a career crossroads. After showing flashes of potential, he'll need to seize opportunities to prove he can develop into a starter rather than remain a backup.