Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era

4 min read
Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era - Image 1
Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era - Image 2
Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era - Image 3
Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era - Image 4

Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era

In Game 3, Pittsburgh Penguins captain Sidney Crosby was called for his first embellishment penalty of his career, reopening discussions that we thought he had moved on from.

Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era

In Game 3, Pittsburgh Penguins captain Sidney Crosby was called for his first embellishment penalty of his career, reopening discussions that we thought he had moved on from.

Article image
Article image
Article image

Penguins’ Sidney Crosby’s embellishment call reopens old questions in a new era originally appeared on The Sporting News. Add The Sporting News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

Sidney Crosby is one of the greatest players in NHL history, but his reputation has never been entirely free of baggage.

In the early stages of his career, he was just as often talked about for his play-acting as he was for his playmaking. Opponents accused him of selling contact and constantly "whining" about calls. Fans debated it endlessly. And for a time, it stuck.

As late as 2014, compilations of Crosby “dives” were still circulating online—some even set to dramatic music like Celine Dion’s My Heart Will Go On, a tongue-in-cheek reminder of how polarizing he once was. Even figures like Don Cherry, then a prominent voice on Hockey Night in Canada, openly called him out for “diving” and “crying.”

Cherry himself would later be fired by Sportsnet in 2019 following controversial on-air comments deemed xenophobic and discriminatory toward immigrants. Still, for much of his broadcasting career, he remained a loud and influential voice in the hockey world—and Crosby was frequently in his crosshairs.

Crosby matured, and so did his game. The talk of embellishment faded, replaced by something far more enduring: dominance, leadership, and legacy. He became the face of the Pittsburgh Penguins, a three-time Stanley Cup champion, and one of the most respected captains the league has ever seen.

MORE: Despite Kyle Dubas' Roster Rejuvenation, The Penguins Are Still In Trouble If Crosby Can't Score

Through the Sidney Crosby Foundation, he has helped fund grassroots hockey programs, including initiatives that provide children with full sets of equipment who otherwise couldn’t afford to play. He’s partnered with the NHLPA’s Goals & Dreams program to deliver complete gear packages to youth hockey organizations. And in countless youth camps, he’s known for the small, unglamorous moments—taping a stick, tying skates, or simply taking time to make a kid feel seen.

That evolution is exactly what makes what happened Wednesday night feel so jarring.

In a 5–2 loss to the Philadelphia Flyers on April 22, Crosby was assessed an embellishment penalty for the first time in his NHL career.

The sequence was simple, almost routine at first glance.

Lined up for a faceoff early in the first period, Crosby took a high stick to the face from Garnet Hathaway. He went down immediately, clutching at the contact point as play stopped. Hathaway, unconvinced, reacted with an exaggerated diving gesture before being escorted toward the penalty box as the crowd erupted in boos.

After a brief conference among officials, the decision came down: matching minors—high-sticking on Hathaway, embellishment on Crosby.

What should have been a Pittsburgh power play instead became four-on-four hockey. And just like that, the moment shifted from routine to controversial.

MORE: Takeaways: Penguins' Strong Start Goes Sideways As Flyers Take Commanding 3-0 Series Lead

The Penguins’ bench looked stunned. Crosby himself appeared visibly frustrated, shaking his head as the call was announced.

Head coach Dan Muse didn’t hide his frustration afterward.

“We don’t have a single embellishment all year,” he told reporters afterward. “Sidney Crosby doesn’t have an embellishment in 21 seasons. So stick’s in his face, and they take both. I disagree on that strongly.

“Not one. Not one for our team all season. We didn’t come in this series to start now. Our guys have done a good job with that, and Sid doesn’t embellish.”

Through the opening stretch of the series, Crosby has already picked up three penalties, including a retaliatory slash in Game 1 that ended his night early. The tone has been physical, emotional, and increasingly tense.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News