The 2026 NFL Draft is just over two weeks away, and for the Dallas Cowboys, the stakes couldn't be higher. For the first time since 2008, they hold two first-round picks, making this the most pivotal draft for the franchise's future in recent memory. The pressure is on to build a roster that can finally break through in the playoffs.
Countless mock drafts have linked the Cowboys to top defensive talents like safety Caleb Downs or edge rusher Rueben Bain Jr. at pick 12. However, a nightmare scenario is brewing: what if they're on the clock and all their premier defensive targets are already gone?
This exact situation was outlined in a recent "What I Would Do" mock draft by Jaime Eisner of The Draft Network. In his projection, the eleven picks before Dallas saw a run on defenders, wiping out the Cowboys' top board. With their preferred options off the table, Eisner had Dallas selecting Oregon safety Dillon Thieneman at 12.
Thieneman is a solid prospect—a versatile defender with great ball skills and combine numbers who could start immediately. But using the 12th overall pick on a safety, a position often devalued in the first round, would be a strategic misstep for a team with glaring needs elsewhere. In this scenario, the Cowboys would likely be desperate to trade down, but if no fair deal materializes, they could be forced into a panic pick that fails to maximize the value of a premium selection.
Compounding the issue, Eisner's mock then had Dallas making another head-scratching move at pick 20, selecting a defensive tackle from Clemson. Back-to-back reaches in the first round would represent a disastrous draft night, squandering a golden opportunity to infuse elite talent into the roster. For Cowboys fans dreaming of a return to glory, this is the draft-day horror story they hope to avoid.
