While the NFL Draft buzz often focuses on the big-name quarterbacks projected to go early, the real intrigue for scouts and general managers sometimes lies deeper in the draft board. This year, two surprising prospects are generating significant behind-the-scenes praise that could make them the hidden gems of the quarterback class.
The first is Penn State's Drew Allar. Entering last season, Allar was viewed as a potential top-tier talent, showcasing a powerful arm and impressive physical tools at 6'5" and 228 pounds. However, a significant ankle injury derailed his final collegiate season and, with it, the Nittany Lions' offensive rhythm. Despite the setback, his pre-injury tape has left a lasting impression on evaluators.
One scout emphasized this potential, telling Fox Sports, "Most people think he’s a Day 3 guy, but I think he should go on Day 2. He looked like a potential first-rounder as a junior... He can play. He’s got a big arm." The scout pointed out that while consistency is a concern, the raw physical attributes are undeniable. For a team willing to develop his talent, Allar represents a high-upside gamble that could pay off massively.
The second name turning heads is North Dakota State's Cole Payton. NDSU has a famous pipeline to the NFL, producing quarterbacks like Carson Wentz and Trey Lance, a history that brings both prestige and heightened scrutiny. While that pedigree might give some teams pause, Payton's own skill set is earning rave reviews.
Scouts are particularly impressed with his dual-threat capabilities and poise. "He can drive the ball down the field," noted one longtime scout. "[He’s got] poise and calmness in the pocket... He can extend plays, a good scrambler. He’s a strong, up-field runner with contact power." An assistant GM added that if Payton had played at a premier Division I program, the hype around him would be considerably louder, suggesting he is a classic case of a small-school standout.
Drafting a quarterback is always a franchise-altering decision, a blend of analytics, intuition, and projection. While the first round will grab the headlines, the real draft-day steals often emerge from the second day or later. For teams in need of a quarterback, keeping a close eye on Drew Allar and Cole Payton could be the key to unlocking their future.
