The NFL Draft is a high-stakes chess match, and few analysts have been as accurate as ESPN's Peter Schrager when it comes to the Dallas Cowboys. For two consecutive years, Schrager has correctly predicted the Cowboys' first-round pick, a feat that makes his latest mock draft projections required reading for every Dallas fan.
Unlike many pundits who flood the zone with weekly mocks, Schrager takes a measured approach, releasing just two per draft cycle. His focus isn't on hot takes or fan service; it's on intel gathered directly from team sources. Following the recent league meetings, he's unveiled his first 2026 mock, and his picks for Dallas at No. 12 and No. 20 are a clear blueprint for a defensive revival.
At pick No. 12, Schrager projects Ohio State safety Caleb Downs. He quotes a source who calls Downs "the smartest player" in the draft and a potential franchise face. For a Cowboys defense that surrendered a league-worst 54 plays of 25+ yards last season, adding a dynamic playmaker like Downs to pair with Jalen Thompson and Malik Hooker could be transformative. The catch? His availability at No. 12 is considered a long shot, with analytics giving him slim odds of falling out of the top ten.
With their second first-rounder at No. 20, Schrager has Dallas targeting Miami (FL) edge rusher Jahfari Mesidor. While older for a prospect at 25, Mesidor is praised as potentially the most polished pass rusher available. His technical prowess and immediate impact potential could provide the perfect complement to Micah Parsons, giving Dallas a formidable and versatile edge duo to terrorize opposing quarterbacks for years to come.
If Schrager's track record holds and the Cowboys land this defensive haul, it would represent a massive step forward for a unit in need of star power and smart, impactful players. All eyes will be on his final mock draft just before the event to see if he's poised for a historic third straight correct call on America's Team.