As the 2026 season heats up, it's time to check the scorecard on your favorite team's early performance. While some playoff favorites are acing the first half of the season, others are flunking hard—and the grades are in.

From an impressive A+ to a quartet of big-market F's, our report card reveals which teams are living up to the hype and which ones are leaving fans frustrated. The top performers are showing championship-caliber consistency, executing on both ends of the field with precision and poise. Their early-season dominance has them poised for a deep playoff run.

But for four major-market contenders, the story is starkly different. Whether it's a sluggish offense, a leaky defense, or simply failing to click as a unit, these teams have earned failing grades that raise serious questions about their postseason aspirations. In a league where momentum is everything, these squads need to turn things around fast—or risk watching the playoffs from home.

Whether your team is acing the test or hitting the books for a midseason comeback, now is the time to gear up with the right apparel to show your support. After all, every season has its ups and downs—but true fans stick through the whole ride.