Every team's most desired NFL Draft do-over: Steelers passing on Dan Marino in 1983 among all-time whiffs

3 min read
Every team's most desired NFL Draft do-over: Steelers passing on Dan Marino in 1983 among all-time whiffs

Every team's most desired NFL Draft do-over: Steelers passing on Dan Marino in 1983 among all-time whiffs

If given the chance, every NFL team would change these draft gaffes

Every team's most desired NFL Draft do-over: Steelers passing on Dan Marino in 1983 among all-time whiffs

If given the chance, every NFL team would change these draft gaffes

Every NFL team has that one draft pick they wish they could take back. While landing a star like Tony Dorsett—who helped the Cowboys win Super Bowl XII just months after being drafted—is the dream, the reality is that franchises often look back on selections that haunt them for decades.

As the 2026 NFL Draft approaches, we’re revisiting the most painful “what-ifs” for each team. These aren’t just minor regrets; they’re franchise-altering decisions that left fans wondering what could have been.

Let’s start with a legendary blunder: the Pittsburgh Steelers passing on Dan Marino in 1983. Marino, a hometown hero from Pitt, fell to the Dolphins at No. 27 while the Steelers selected defensive tackle Gabriel Rivera. Rivera’s career was tragically cut short, while Marino rewrote the record books and became a Hall of Famer. Imagine Marino in black and gold—it’s a thought that still stings in Steel City.

Sometimes, a bad pick doesn’t hurt immediately but lingers for years. Take the Arizona Cardinals in 2006. They selected Matt Leinart 10th overall, passing on Jay Cutler—who went one pick later—and a deep running back class that included DeAngelo Williams and Joseph Addai. While Arizona reached the Super Bowl in 2008, Leinart never became the franchise quarterback they hoped for, leaving a long-term void under center.

Other misses are clear from day one. In 1991, the Atlanta Falcons used the No. 3 overall pick on defensive back Bruce Pickens, hoping he’d pair with Deion Sanders. Instead, Pickens was gone in less than three years, while future Hall of Fame tackle Todd Light—selected two spots later—anchored lines for over a decade and won a Super Bowl with the Rams.

Quarterback gambles can be especially costly. In 2003, the Baltimore Ravens traded their first-round pick to move up and select Kyle Boller. Despite having a strong defense, Baltimore’s offense struggled for years as Boller failed to live up to expectations, proving that missing on a QB can set a team back for an entire era.

These stories remind us that the draft is part science, part luck—and even the best teams aren’t immune to mistakes. As prospects prepare to hear their names called this year, front offices will be working overtime to avoid adding a new chapter to their list of regrets.

Like this article?

Order custom jerseys for your team with free design

Related Topics

Related News

Back to All News