The Denver Broncos are facing a critical question as they navigate the aftermath of Bo Nix's broken ankle—an injury that sidelined the young quarterback during the AFC Conference Championship. Head coach Sean Payton has hinted that the team may look to add another signal-caller, especially after Jarrett Stidham's underwhelming playoff performance, where he completed just 54.8% of his passes for 133 yards, a touchdown, and an interception. With only Sam Ehlinger—who hasn't thrown an NFL pass since 2022—behind Stidham, the Broncos clearly need more depth and competition under center.

So, who could step in to help install Payton's offense and provide a reliable backup while Nix recovers? Here are four intriguing options that could shake things up in Denver.

1. Jimmy Garoppolo
At 34, Garoppolo is reportedly mulling retirement, but he remains unsigned and brings a wealth of experience. Over the past two seasons, he backed up 2025 NFL MVP Matthew Stafford, proving he can thrive in a supportive role. Like Nix, Garoppolo prioritizes ball security over a cannon arm, and his résumé includes two Super Bowl appearances. He'd be the perfect bridge quarterback—steady, proven, and ready to keep the offense humming until Nix is fully healthy.

2. Will Levis
After the Titans drafted Cam Ward with the No. 1 pick, Levis was shown the door. Now 27 and fully recovered from a shoulder injury that cost him last season, the former second-round pick is likely eager for a fresh start. Learning under Sean Payton could be the springboard his career needs, and with Mitchell Trubisky locked in as Tennessee's backup, the Titans might be open to trading Levis for the right price. He's a high-upside gamble worth considering.

3. Anthony Richardson
Would the Broncos take a low-risk flier on one of the most talented—yet injury-prone—quarterbacks in recent memory? Richardson, the former No. 4 overall pick, is a dynamic playmaker with a rocket arm and elite athleticism. While his injury history is a concern, his potential as a developmental prospect is undeniable. Denver would need to work out fair trade compensation, but having a project like Richardson on the roster could pay huge dividends down the road.

4. A Trade or Free Agent Surprise
Beyond these names, the Broncos could explore other avenues—whether through a mid-level trade or a veteran free agent looking for one more shot. Sean Payton has a knack for maximizing quarterback talent, and with Nix's recovery timeline uncertain, adding a capable arm could be the difference between a playoff push and a rebuilding year.

For now, Broncos fans should keep an eye on the QB room—because the next move could define the team's season. Whether it's a seasoned veteran like Garoppolo or a high-risk, high-reward talent like Richardson, Denver is clearly not settling for the status quo.