To rotate or not to rotate? With a crucial European semi-final on the horizon, Crystal Palace manager Oliver Glasner faced a classic managerial dilemma. Against his usual instincts, he made five changes for the Premier League clash with Newcastle, a decision that highlighted the intense competition for places fueled by their Conference League run.

The biggest winner of this squad rotation might just be Jean-Philippe Mateta. Handed a start in Europe due to a suspension and then introduced against a tiring Newcastle, the French striker seized his moment with both hands. His recent surge—three goals in two games—has ignited a fascinating debate: has he reclaimed the starting striker role from record signing Jorgen Strand Larsen?

While it may be too early to declare a definitive winner in that battle, Palace suddenly find themselves in an enviable position. After struggling for consistent firepower for much of the season, they now have two potent options vying for the number nine shirt, a headache any manager would welcome.

Mateta's resurgence isn't just a short-term boost; it's cementing his place in club history. His recent strikes brought his total to 59 goals for Palace, making him the 16th-highest scorer in the club's history across all competitions. More impressively, by reaching 10 Premier League goals this season, he joins the iconic Wilfried Zaha as the only Palace players to have hit double digits in three separate top-flight campaigns.

After a January move to Serie A fell through, some wondered about Mateta's future at Selhurst Park. But goals are the ultimate currency for a striker, and his match-winning contribution against Newcastle was a powerful statement. The roaring approval from the stands suggests the vocal majority have already welcomed him back into the fold, his boots doing all the talking he needs.