The NFL offseason is full of surprises, and the Pittsburgh Steelers' quarterback room is no exception. As the team prepares for the 2026 season, they've signaled a commitment to carrying three quarterbacks on their 53-man roster. With Aaron Rodgers potentially returning to the fold, that could leave veteran signal-caller Mason Rudolph as the odd man out. Given the unlikelihood of the Steelers parting ways with young talents like Will Howard or Drew Allar, a trade for Rudolph seems increasingly plausible. Here are three potential landing spots for the experienced QB.
Indianapolis Colts
The Colts face significant uncertainty under center. Daniel Jones is recovering from a torn Achilles, and Anthony Richardson has reportedly requested a trade. This leaves Indianapolis in need of a reliable backup who can step in and start if necessary. Rudolph, with his proven ability to manage games and deliver in clutch moments, would be an ideal fit. He offers stability and experience—qualities the Colts desperately need as they navigate a turbulent quarterback situation.
New York Jets
The Jets appear all-in on Geno Smith for 2026, but that plan carries considerable risk. Behind Smith, their projected QB2 options are limited to Bailey Zappe or rookie Cade Klubnik, a fourth-round pick. Adding Rudolph would provide a much more trustworthy backup option. Moreover, his presence could push Smith early in the season, ensuring the Jets have a capable fallback if the offense stumbles. For a team with playoff aspirations, Rudolph's experience and poise would be a valuable asset.
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
The Buccaneers are in win-now mode, but their depth behind starter Baker Mayfield is a concern. Currently, Jake Browning—who was demoted to QB3 by the Cincinnati Bengals last season—is the primary backup. One injury to Mayfield could derail Tampa Bay's season. Rudolph would be a solid, low-cost addition, likely available for a Day 3 draft pick. His reliability and ability to run a pro-style offense would give the Buccaneers a safety net, allowing them to compete with confidence.
As the Steelers navigate their offseason moves, keep an eye on these three teams. For a bargain price, any of them could land a quarterback who knows how to win in the NFL.