The Arizona Cardinals hold a pivotal decision with the third overall pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. Conventional wisdom suggests they will target a premier pass rusher or offensive tackle to fortify their roster. However, a fascinating curveball has emerged from draft analysts Todd McShay and Peter Schrager: Notre Dame running back Jeremiyah Love.
Love is widely considered one of the most dynamic talents in this class, but his fit in Arizona raises immediate questions. The Cardinals recently re-signed veteran workhorse James Conner and added Tyler Allgeier in free agency, creating a crowded backfield. Drafting Love could lead to a logjam, leaving one of these talented runners underutilized.
So, how could this scenario realistically unfold? The path hinges on the Cardinals' draft strategy. Reports indicate the front office desires to trade down from the third spot, mirroring their successful 2023 maneuver to select tackle Paris Johnson Jr. Their goal would be to acquire more capital while still landing a top offensive lineman.
But what if a trade partner doesn't materialize? If they're stuck at No. 3 and don't see a tackle worthy of that selection, their focus would shift to the elite pass rushers available. Here's where it gets interesting. Suppose their top defensive target, say David Bailey, is snatched by the New York Jets picking second. The Cardinals might then view the other top edge prospect, Arvell Reese, as a slight reach for the third pick.
This perfect storm—no trade, their preferred tackle off the board, and their top pass rusher gone—could force Arizona to consider the "best player available." With McShay noting internal support for Love and Schrager labeling him a wild card, the Cardinals might just pull the trigger on the explosive Notre Dame star, opting for elite offensive firepower over a positional need.