The report card has come, and this while this one may not hang on the refrigerator long-term or get slipped into the box of keepsakes in the attic, it likely won't get the Cowboys in any trouble.
Scanning some of the major outlets the day after the NFL draft wrapped up, the Cowboys earned good to very good grades from nearly everyone. There was unanimous praise for safety Caleb Downs, especially with Dallas landing him outside the top 10. And most analysts saw enough upside in edge rusher Malachi Lawrence to forgive the Cowboys for grabbing him a little earlier than pre-draft rankings may have suggested.
The rest of the Cowboys' 2026 draft class got mixed reviews, with Jaishawn Barham, Drew Shelton, Devin Moore, LT Overton, and Anthony Smith all being seen as depth pieces with varying degrees of potential as contributors, depending on who was doing the evaluating.
And don't forget that the club traded for 49ers linebacker Dee Winters in the middle of the weekend. That will mean an improvement to the middle level of the Dallas defense and should count as extra credit toward the Cowboys' overall draft score.
The result? Final grades that are all tightly bunched in the A-and-B range. Nobody thought Dallas aced the draft with a perfect mark, but no one gave them anything lower than a B-, either.
For most of us, that kind of report card would still have earned us a trip to Red Lobster to celebrate.
The Cowboys had a savvy Day 1 by trading up for Downs, a do-it-all playmaker, and later gaining two extra fourth-rounders from the Eagles to trade down and land Lawrence, who offers plenty of upside. Dallas was wise not to get caught up in replacing Micah Parsons with one of the top edge rushers in this draft. Instead, the Cowboys got a leader in the secondary with Downs—the secondary desperately needed help—and they now have depth on the edge with Lawrence, Barham and Overton, veteran Rashan Gary and last year’s second-round pick, Donovan Ezeiruaku.
The Cowboys have done exactly what they seemingly set out to do when they traded away superstar pass rusher Micah Parsons, adding a horde of playmakers to what looks to be an ascending defensive core. Coming out of the first round with uber-versatile safety Caleb Downs and explosive pass-rusher Malachi Lawrence gives Dallas two day-one impact players. Downs could be the straw-that-stirs-the-drink type defensive back for the Cowboys for years, bringing instincts and skill to multiple spots in the back end. And Lawrence (who was attained with one of the picks acquired in the Parsons trade) takes some much needed heat off the edge, showing twitchy movement skills and top-tier closing burst. The addition of linebacker Jaishawn Barham could bring immediate return, too: He’s a tenacious, highly physical defender with experience playing off the ball (where he’ll reportedly start for the Cowboys) and off the edge as a situational rusher. Add in a draft-day trade for 49ers linebacker Dee Winters (for this year’s fifth-round pick), and the Cowboys defense could look a whole lot different—and much improved—in 2026 and beyond.
The Cowboys had plans to load up on defense with no real offensive concerns except getting some tackle help which they did. Jerry Jones delivered a lot more pop for the pass defense that needed it with new coordinator Christian Parker. They did a good job trying to emulate the Seahawks' deep pass rush by committee.
This was the year of positional value not mattering. It was a weak class at premium positions with elite prospects at non-premium spots. That was the widespread mantra of draftniks in this class and many used it as a reason to push certain players up their boards. With all of that drumbeat heading into the draft, it baffles me that Caleb Downs was available at 11th overall. Downs is an instinctive pass defender who can also step in to stop the run. He does a lot of everything at an elite level. Downs was a steal for Dallas.
With their second-first round pick, Dallas took a bigger swing (read: more risk) on Malachi Lawrence. He’s a speed demon with good production, but his size (6’4/253) could make him a liability against the run, which was not his strong suit in college.
As expected, the Cowboys didn’t let their foot off the gas when it came to drafting defensive talents. Jaishawn Barham has a unique profile. He split his time between off-ball and EDGE duties in college. He posted his best numbers at Michigan in 2025, tallying 10 TFLs and four sacks. I’m not entirely sure what his role will look like in the NFL, but I’m intrigued.
Moving up one spot to get the best safety in the draft — Caleb Downs — at No. 11 was an excellent move for the defense. Moving back three spots to No. 23 might have cost them a better option but ended up Malachi Lawrence, who wasn’t a consensus first-round pick. Edge Jaishawn Barham (92), CB Devin Moore (114) and edge LT Overton (137) give new defensive coordinator Christian Parker more talent to develop. OT Drew Shelton (112) has high upside.
Dallas had the steal of the first round, trading two fifth-round picks to move up one spot for Downs; he should be a long-time defensive leader able to make plays in the deep half, flat and the box. The 'Boys moved down from Green Bay's first-round selection, acquired in the Micah Parsons trade, to pick Lawrence, who has potential because of his length and athleticism but carries risk as a late riser in the evaluation process. They traded their original Day 2 picks for veterans Quinnen Williams and George Pickens but were still able to select Barham, a versatile second-level defender, in the third round after sending defensive lineman Osa Odighizuwa to the 49ers back in March.
Shelton's 2025 game tape did not scream fourth-round pick to me, but the team can develop him into a swing tackle in time. Dallas received two fourth-round picks from Philadelphia in the teams' first-round trade. They used one of those selections on the physical but injury-plagued Moore and the other on Overton, who might compete to replace Osa Odighizuwa on the interior. The Cowboys filled a glaring need by trading a fifth-round pick to the 49ers for LB Dee Winters. Look for Smith to fight for a roster spot as a receiver who can stretch the field.
The Caleb Downs selection was a no-brainer and a home run. He’s talented and a leader who will solidify the back end of a defense that desperately needs it. I’m a little cooler on Malachi Lawrence, whom I was more comfortable taking later than in the first round. But Lawrence has speed and can get after the quarterback, a skill set that’s always valued. Drew Shelton has talent but was inconsistent, so he gives offensive coordinator Klayton Adams an interesting project to work with. LT Overton had a disappointing season, but he’s heavy-handed and can move along the defensive line. His inside-outside ability will make him useful.
Barham is a twitchy athlete who is relentless in getting after the ball carrier. He had experience as an edge defender and lining up off-ball in college. While he had flashes at both spots, he can work himself out of plays when aligned off the ball at linebacker and lacks ideal size on the edge. That might not make him a player for everybody. He does both well enough that there’s potential if he’s able to continue to hone his talent. And he’s actually a cleaner fit in Christian Parker’s defensive scheme than you’d think if used like how Zack Baun was in Philadelphia, another tweener-type moved off-ball with forays on the edge.
The talk of draft season was that the Cowboys would trade up if one of their favorite defensive prospects was there for the taking. They were also identified as a trade-down candidate with their No. 20 pick. Jerry Jones made both of those predictions come to life -- all while securing a couple of terrific defensive prospects to fill his team's glaring needs.
Caleb Downs remaining on the board outside the top 10 was the catalyst for a transaction with the Dolphins. He has the potential to be a long-term leader of this defense.
All kinds of help is on the way in the edge rusher unit. This group was a glaring weakness following the Micah Parsons trade and became the focal point of Dallas' draft plans. Malachi Lawrence was available at No. 23 after the Cowboys made an intra-division swap with the Eagles, Jaishawn Barham came off the board the following day and LT Overton made it three consecutive days with an edge rusher pick.